A-HH4199
From Studyplace
Reflections on Formative Influence
Tuesdays, 7:20 to 9:00
541 Dodge Hall
Teachers College • Columbia University
| MEETINGS | ROBBIE'S REFLECTIONS | TALK | ||
| From Childhood to PhD | ||||
| 1/25 • 1 | Albert Camus | TM • TR | ||
| 2/1 • 2 | Henry Adams | TM • TR | ||
| 2/8 • 3 | José Ortega y Gasset | TM • TR | ||
| Nietzsche | • TR | |||
| Ed Thought in the West | • TR | |||
| 2/15 • 4 | Plato | TM • TR | ||
| 2/22 • 5 | Dante | TM • TR | ||
| 3/1 • 6 | Rousseau | TM • TR | ||
| Power and Pedagogy | ||||
| 3/8 • 7 | Machiavelli | TM • TR | ||
| 3/22 • 8 | Goethe | TM • TR | ||
| 3/29 • 9 | Kant | TM • TR | ||
| 4/5 • 10 | Hegel | TM • TR | ||
| Social Thought | ||||
| 4/12 • 11 | Karl Marx | TM • TR | ||
| 4/19 • 12 | Max Weber | TM • TR | ||
| 4/26 • 13 | Horkheimer & Adorno | TM • TR | ||
| 5/3 • 14 | C. Wright Mills | TM • TR | ||
| Envoi | ||||
| 5/10 • 15 | Jane Jacobs | TM • TR | ||
| CONTEXT | ||||
| 1939-1957 | Childhood & Youth | • Talk | ||
| 1957-1961 | College & Europe | • Talk | ||
| 1961-1968 | Graduate Studies | • Talk | ||
| 1967-1984 | Ed Thought in the West | • Talk | ||
| 1984-2001 | Technology & Education | • Talk | ||
| 2002-2010 | Social Theory | • Talk | ||
An Invitation
In September 1961, I waited outside Professor Lawrence Cremin's office, wanting permission to join his colloquium on the history of American educational thought. After a brief eternity, Mrs. Zolot, the secretary for Philosophy and the Social Sciences, a woman at once kindly and curt, instructed me to go speak to the Professor.
Cremin, an attentive, gracious man of 35 or so, listened to me explain — I was starting to work on a Ph.D. in Columbia's history department, having graduated from Princeton the previous June — Could I participate in his colloquium, which was key to my interest in the history of educational thought? He welcomed me in the colloquium, suggesting that I sit in as well on his lecture course, a prerequisite. That was my start here, and I have been here ever since, as a student, and from fall 1967, as a member of the faculty. Now, after this semester, I am retiring from the faculty, which naturally has me thinking back a bit, asking questions —
- What have I learned?
- Why did I try to do what I tried to do?
- What continuities and changes of note have I witnessed?
- Whither goes the future, here and in the world at large?
This course, My Canon, is an opportunity to answer, as best I can. Anyone who wants to join in is welcome.
In My Canon, I will reflect on the history of educational thought. I will also examine my personal engagement with that history. And I will further consider the historical context — in education, in academe, and in the world at large — within which my engagement with the history of educational thought took place.
I suspect that the last of these, the historical context, may be the most valuable of the matters at issue. To refresh my memories, I have been reading some large, comprehensive histories — Postwar by Tony Judt for Europe, and Grand Expectations and Restless Giant by James T. Patterson for the United States. These accentuate the succession of events — history as one thing after another — whereas what stands out for me is the subjective interrelation of historical situations and developments, the way my peculiar experience of one thing colors my experience of another. My Canon will recount how my engagement with important works of educational theory interacted with my experience of a lived historical context over a 50-year period. I hope others may find it informative.
What will come of it, I am not sure. I have offered neither this course before, nor one like it, and I've never taken one like it, either. So I don't know exactly what will happen. Preparing it has taken the better part of a lifetime, and my plan of reflection has an agenda, the skeleton of which is at the right on your screen, with links to Wiki pages and from those to other materials, all of which are extensible by each of us participating in the inquiry. I expect to start our meetings with something of a monologue, which should turn interactive as it proceeds. There will be pointers on a growing number of pages linking to stuff to read, to listen to, and to watch, which each can engage and add to as interests move and as constraints allow.
Students registered for academic credit should study a work of substance to add to Your Canon and post your reflections to the course website about why, in your cultural, historical, and professional context, you include it in Your Canon and how it helps you form your sense of self and your circumstances. And of course, auditors may do so as well.


Except where